| 2026 | Mark Costanza / Jeronimo Esteve |
| 2025 | Scott Strickland / Jimmy Chestnut |
| 2024 | Scott Strickland / Jimmy Chestnut |
| 2023 | Trevor Randolph / Chris DeJohn |
| 2022 | Stewart Hagestad / Mike McBride |
| 2021 | Stewart Hagestad / Mike McBride |
| 2020 | Cancelled |
| 2019 | Chris Stutts / Stephen Summers |
| 2018 | Brett Boner / Stephen Woodard |
| 2017 | Kenny Ebalo / Shane Sigsbee |
| 2016 | Chris Troy / James Nicholas |
| 2015 | Roger Newsom / Adam Horton |
| 2014 | Luis Fernando Barco / Patricio Alzamora |
| 2013 | Max Buckley / Max Christiana |
| 2012 | Parker Smith / Dan Crockett |
| 2011 | Parker Smith / Dan Crockett |
| 2010 | Parker Smith / Philip Breeding |
| 2009 | Gregory E. Rohlf / Jeffrey Fenn Putman |
| 2008 | Frank Fairman / Nathan Smith |
| 2007 | Frank Fairman / Nathan Smith |
| 2006 | Bart Goodwin / Jeff Makohon |
| 2005 | Greg Kennedy / Kyle Harper |
| 2004 | Mark Love / Jay Cason |
| 2003 | James D. Graham / Andrew R. Svoboda |
| 2002 | Rob Martin, III / Phillip Huff |
| 2001 | James Reid / Tripp Davis |
| 2000 | James Reid / Tripp Davis |
| 1999 | Tom Yellin / Jack Kiernan |
| 1998 | Jody Fanagan / Noel Fox |
| 1997 | Pascal Grizot / Francois Illouz |
| 1996 | Jamie Crow / Brady Exber |
| 1995 | Tom Yellin / Jack Kiernan |
| 1994 | Paul Demick / Mike Riley |
| 1993 | Chris Cupit / Boyd Dethero |
| 1992 | Jimmy Chapman / Mike Hoyle |
| 1991 | Peter Van Ingen / R. J. Nakashian |
| 1990 | Adam Spring / Jonathan Jame |
| 1989 | Bob Lewis, Jr. / Robert M. Fairchild |
| 1988 | Steven Spencer / Larry Tedesco |
| 1987 | Randy Sonnier / Robert Mckinney |
| 1986 | Neil Christie / John P. O’Hara |
| 1985 | Warren Choate / Joe Reynolds |
| 1984 | Neil Christie / John P. O’Hara |
| 1983 | Jerry Courville, Sr. / Jerry Courville, Jr. |
| 1982 | Robert A. Horak / David C. Boeff |
| 1981 | Clint Mcdermott / John Aylsworth |
| 1980 | John Birmingham / Frank Fuhrer |
| 1979 | Jerry Courville, Sr. / Jerry Courville, Jr. |
| 1978 | Jerry Courville, Sr. / Jerry Courville, Jr. |
| 1977 | Gerald P. Nye, Jr. / Martin R. West, III |
| 1976 | Richard Siderowf / Howard Kaskel |
| 1975 | Neil Christie / John P. O’Hara |
| 1974 | Jim Bostwicvk / Pete Bostwick |
| 1973 | Mike Ford / John Hall |
| 1972 | George Marucci / Richard Bendall |
| 1971 | E. Tutwiler / William Hyndman |
| 1970 | G. H. Bostwick, Jr. / James Bostwick |
| 1969 | Stanley Hilinski / Tom Gorman |
| 1968 | Craig Wood Harmon / Richard M. Harmon |
| 1967 | Eugene Francis / William Edwards |
| 1966 | Dr. Ted Lencsyk / Henry Budney |
| 1965 | Carl Timsen / Richard Remsen |
| 1964 | Ralph Bogart / Robert Brownell |
| 1963 | William Hyndman, III / Thomas Hyndman |
| 1962 | William Care / Ellis Taylor |
| 1961 | William Hyndman, III / Thomas Hyndman |
| 1960 | Ralph Bogart / Robert Brownell |
| 1959 | Deane Beman / William I. Buppert |
| 1958 | Deane Beman / William I. Buppert |
| 1957 | Ralph Bogart / Robert Brownell |
| 1956 | Robert Wilke / Lawrence Bell |
| 1955 | Ralph Bogart / Robert Brownell |
| 1954 | Ralph Bogart / Robert Brownell |
| 1953 | Frank Strafaci / Don Cherry |
| 1952 | Mal Galletta / Gordon Stott |
| 1951 | William Dear, Jr. / Kenneth Gordon |
| 1950 | Billy Edwards / Tim Holland |
| 1949 | William J. Schappa, Jr. / Edward B. Vaughan |
| 1948 | William J. Schappa, Jr. / Edward B. Vaughan |
| 1947 | Robert Sweeney / Christopher Dunphy |
| 1946 | Richard D. Chapman / Richard L. Hackett |
| 1941 | William Y. Dear, Jr. / Karl F. Kellerman, Jr. |
| 1940 | William P. Turnesa / Udo M. Reinach |
| 1939 | William P. Turnesa / Udo M. Reinach |
| 1938 | Jack R. Creavy / Richard D. Chapman |
| 1937 | Edmund H. Driggs, Jr. / W. Neal Fulkrson |
| 1936 | Thomas Goodwin / Joseph F. Gagliardi |
| 1935 | William S. Meany, Jr. / Robert Grant |
| 1934 | George T. Dunlap, Jr. / E.Leonard Beard, Jr. |
| 1933 | Mark J. Stuart / Edmund Held |
